E-ISSN 2534-9821
 

Original Research 


Conventional cytology versus liquid based cytology for evaluation of cervical smears – A study of 300 cases

Rupali Bavikar, Meesha Zaheer, Archana Buch, Rajeshwari Raishankar, Rumaanah Khan, Charusheela Gore.

Abstract
Background: Over the years, different studies conducted have established the advantages of liquid based cytology(LBC) over conventional preparations(CP) in cervical smears screening. However, the high cost of machinery required for the preparations still limits its usage in low-resource countries. This study aims to evaluate the performance of a low cost LBC method, EziPREP™ technique against conventional preparations for cervical screening.
Materials and Method: This was a cross sectional study comprising of 300 consequtive cervical samples over a period of 2 year. CP smears were prepared as per the standard technique using ayre’s spatula while for LBC sample was obtained on endocervical brush followed by detaching the head of brush into the fixative vials of LBC. The LBC samples were processed as per the manufacturer's protocol. Both CP and LBC smears were stained using standard Papanicolaou stain & H&E stain protocol. Slides were analysed by two pathologists independently.
Results: The unsatisfactory rate for CP was 5%, main cause being obscuring haemorrhage and inflammation, whereas on LBC samples it was 1.4%, owing to inadequate cellular material. Uniform distribution was more in LBC smears, with minimal overlapping.
The morphological details were comparable in both sets of smears.
The pathogenic organisms, like Gardenella(31%) & Candida(20%) were detected in more CP smears, Trichomonas was seen equally in both smears(3%).
There was a 98% concordance in cytologic diagnosis between CP and LBC smears.
Screening time was notably reduced in LBC smears (3±1minutes vs 5±1 minutes for CP)
Conclusion: This low-cost LBC method holds promise in providing monolayered cervical smears with a clear background. It might carve the way for inclusion of liquid based cytology methods for cervical cancer screening on a larger scale in the low resourse countries.

Key words: Cervical cancer screening, Conventional cytology, Liquid Based Cytology, EziPREP™


 
ARTICLE TOOLS
Abstract
PDF Fulltext
How to cite this articleHow to cite this article
Citation Tools
Related Records
 Articles by Rupali Bavikar
Articles by Meesha Zaheer
Articles by Archana Buch
Articles by Rajeshwari Raishankar
Articles by Rumaanah Khan
Articles by Charusheela Gore
on Google
on Google Scholar


How to Cite this Article
Pubmed Style

Bavikar R, Zaheer M, Buch A, Raishankar R, Khan R, Gore C. Conventional cytology versus liquid based cytology for evaluation of cervical smears – A study of 300 cases. Int J Med Rev Case Rep. 2023; 7(1): 39-46. doi:10.5455/IJMRCR.172-1650453121


Web Style

Bavikar R, Zaheer M, Buch A, Raishankar R, Khan R, Gore C. Conventional cytology versus liquid based cytology for evaluation of cervical smears – A study of 300 cases. https://www.mdpub.net/?mno=20692 [Access: December 17, 2023]. doi:10.5455/IJMRCR.172-1650453121


AMA (American Medical Association) Style

Bavikar R, Zaheer M, Buch A, Raishankar R, Khan R, Gore C. Conventional cytology versus liquid based cytology for evaluation of cervical smears – A study of 300 cases. Int J Med Rev Case Rep. 2023; 7(1): 39-46. doi:10.5455/IJMRCR.172-1650453121



Vancouver/ICMJE Style

Bavikar R, Zaheer M, Buch A, Raishankar R, Khan R, Gore C. Conventional cytology versus liquid based cytology for evaluation of cervical smears – A study of 300 cases. Int J Med Rev Case Rep. (2023), [cited December 17, 2023]; 7(1): 39-46. doi:10.5455/IJMRCR.172-1650453121



Harvard Style

Bavikar, R., Zaheer, . M., Buch, . A., Raishankar, . R., Khan, . R. & Gore, . C. (2023) Conventional cytology versus liquid based cytology for evaluation of cervical smears – A study of 300 cases. Int J Med Rev Case Rep, 7 (1), 39-46. doi:10.5455/IJMRCR.172-1650453121



Turabian Style

Bavikar, Rupali, Meesha Zaheer, Archana Buch, Rajeshwari Raishankar, Rumaanah Khan, and Charusheela Gore. 2023. Conventional cytology versus liquid based cytology for evaluation of cervical smears – A study of 300 cases. International Journal of Medical Reviews and Case Reports, 7 (1), 39-46. doi:10.5455/IJMRCR.172-1650453121



Chicago Style

Bavikar, Rupali, Meesha Zaheer, Archana Buch, Rajeshwari Raishankar, Rumaanah Khan, and Charusheela Gore. "Conventional cytology versus liquid based cytology for evaluation of cervical smears – A study of 300 cases." International Journal of Medical Reviews and Case Reports 7 (2023), 39-46. doi:10.5455/IJMRCR.172-1650453121



MLA (The Modern Language Association) Style

Bavikar, Rupali, Meesha Zaheer, Archana Buch, Rajeshwari Raishankar, Rumaanah Khan, and Charusheela Gore. "Conventional cytology versus liquid based cytology for evaluation of cervical smears – A study of 300 cases." International Journal of Medical Reviews and Case Reports 7.1 (2023), 39-46. Print. doi:10.5455/IJMRCR.172-1650453121



APA (American Psychological Association) Style

Bavikar, R., Zaheer, . M., Buch, . A., Raishankar, . R., Khan, . R. & Gore, . C. (2023) Conventional cytology versus liquid based cytology for evaluation of cervical smears – A study of 300 cases. International Journal of Medical Reviews and Case Reports, 7 (1), 39-46. doi:10.5455/IJMRCR.172-1650453121